Bomb#20
Contributor
- Joined
- Sep 27, 2004
- Messages
- 10,260
- Location
- California
- Gender
- It's a free country.
- Basic Beliefs
- Rationalism
You know perfectly well that economics is not a zero sum game, yet in your economic reasoning you blithely take for granted that it is. Psychiatrists call this "double bookkeeping"; progressives seem peculiarly susceptible to it.Because wealth disparity is the problem that income taxes, as currently interpreted, are blatantly and obviously failing to alleviate. There's a cancer at the top of our economic ladder, draining the entire system dry and contributing next to nothing to society for our pains.Why does the Left love to compute income taxes as percentage of wealth and not income. They are called income taxes for a reason.
To become a multibillionaire means one of four things. It means people paid you billions of dollars in exchange for you providing them with goods or services they liked better than keeping their billions of dollars. That's not "contributing next to nothing to society". That's contributing something worth more billions to society than the billionaires received. The trades were voluntary; if both parties didn't benefit then one of them wouldn't have volunteered. Mutually beneficial trades do not "drain the entire system dry"; mutually beneficial trades are what made the entire system un-dry in the first place.
Or it means people didn't pay you billions of dollars, so you don't have billions of dollars -- you just have something that didn't exist until you caused it to exist, and "multibillionaire" is a measurement only of how much other people want what you caused to exist. It's hypothetical billions -- billions you would receive if you counterfactually agreed to sell your stuff. Entire systems are not "drained dry" by hypothetical trades and by people wanting your stuff more than they used to.
Or it means some other multibillionaire voluntarily decided to gift you his billions of dollars or gift you his stuff other people wish was theirs. That contributes next to nothing, true, but it also doesn't drain any system dry; everybody else is just as un-dry as he was before. Actually, less dry, usually, since the community as a whole typically takes a cut in inheritance taxes.
Or it means you took billions of dollars by force, or got people to give you the money by lying to them about what you were giving them in return. That really is a cancer draining the entire system dry and contributing nothing; if you think that's how those at the top of our economic ladder became multibillionaires, show your work.
Taking private property rights seriously is what drove the rate of people dying on the streets to its current historic low. If we choose to confiscate someone's property for no better reason than because somebody else wants it and forty million assholes deliberately deceive themselves into thinking taking it away from him is the way to save other people from dying on the streets, choices become habits become character. In societies run by people with that character a lot more people die on the streets.People die on the streets, just so these forty assholes can watch imaginary numbers get bigger on their money managers' screen every so often.
The difference between you and the antisemites is that they feel the problems of society are caused by a parasitic minority group we should get rid of, whereas you, in contrast, feel the problems of society are caused by a parasitic minority group we should get rid of.<expletive deleted> these people. They wouldn't spit on your grave to put out a fire, don't suck their dick for free. You owe nothing to them and they don't give a <expletive deleted> about you.