• Welcome to the Internet Infidels Discussion Board.

Which movie did you watch today and how would you rate it?

If it has science and the story is fiction......
How much science is there in Star Wars? Is Star Wars sci-fi?

It's a romantic adventure story - farm boy discovers prowess as a swordsman, defeats the black knight and destroys his castle, gets the princess (who, in fine aristocratic tradition, is also his sister).

It's set in the past. ("A long time ago, in a galaxy far, far away..." is the opening statement).

There are technologies that are beyond our present ability, but these are basically just magic, per Clarke's Law, with no explanation of how they might work, or what (if any) science underlies them. Some are directly contrary to science as we understand it; And some are not even technological - "The force" is pure supernaturalism.

So the ONLY thing that makes Star Wars sci-fi is that it's set in spaaaaace. But few people would say that it's NOT sci-fi.
 
Abraham Lincoln vampire hunter isn’t a historical movie just because Lincoln was a historical figure.
And the same is true of Braveheart, despite William Wallace being an historical figure.

Indeed, it probably makes more sense to classify Braveheart as science fiction than as historical. It did showcase some allegedly novel military technologies, after all.
 
Back
Top Bottom